(PARTIAL-)CROSSPOST: JARED SHURIN: THE Reality of Fantasy: “This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me” by Ilona Andrews
The fictional series Maggie loves is hopeless grimdark, but the novel itself is not. Plus how truly ultimate plot armor can, in skillful hands, be not a minus but a significant story-telling plus:
Andrews, Ilona. 2026. This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me. New York: Tor. <https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781250377265/thiskingdomwillnotkillme/> <https://us.macmillan.com/series/maggietheundying>.
Certainly the most entertaining novel I have read in the past half-year or so:
(PARTIAL-)CROSSPOST: JARED SHURIN: THE Reality of Fantasy: “This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me” by Ilona Andrews
<https://reactormag.com/book-review-this-kingdom-will-not-kill-me-by-ilona-andrews/> <https://reactormag.com>
A novel that “understands the heart of the reader, the desire not only to read the story, but also to be a part of it.”
By Jared Shurin
Published on April 9, 2026
Portal fantasies, or isekai, have a long tradition…. A more modern subset of the portal fantasy features readers or players being pulled into their favourite fantasy worlds…. From Dungeon Crawler Carl to Long Live Evil, there’s a clear zeitgeist at play…. This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me is firmly in this tradition: a fan traveling (somehow) into her favorite fantasy world. But… monkey’s paw curls… and… putting it into direct conflict with modern, “real world” morality…. Marigold (or Maggie, as she prefers) is a passionate fan of a particular… series…. They’re brutal and complicated, but they are her happy place. Relass is far closer to Westeros than Tolkien or Narnia. Much like A Song of Ice and Fire, it is a land with competing noble houses, an unstable throne, horrible monsters, and worse people. Also like A Song of Ice and Fire, it is famously unfinished. Maggie’s devoured both books in the series over and over and over again, while still waiting for the third volume to be delivered by its enigmatic author. Even as an adult, she still finds comfort on the streets of Kair Toren.
However, when Maggie actually wakes up on those blood-soaked streets, she finds them much less comfortable. Life in a grimdark fantasy is, as it turns out, both grim and dark…. Her ferocious desire to live will lead her to do amoral, and potentially even terrible things. Second, she can’t actually die. Stabbed during the robbery, she bleeds to death[—]and wakes up, fully healed. With a head full of series trivia, Maggie knows more about the characters and events around her than the canonical protagonists do. She’s a potent seer, with the ability to influence events and outcomes to suit her will. She’s also encased in true plot armor….
This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me is, on its simplest level, Maggie’s progression fantasy: Her journey from the gutters to the highest courts in the land, growing in power along the way. Along the way she meets assassins and knights, monsters and mages, and explores a fantasy world that’s even richer and more complex than she had ever imagined….. Ilona Andrews keeps the tension high by challenging Maggie in both conventional and unconventional ways.
This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me is nakedly fan service. It is a story about the experience of entering into, and attempting to master, a fantasy world. Kingdom is the ultimate wish fulfillment of every “true” fan—the desire to enter your favourite story and to make it about yourself—but it is also about the dark side of that fantasy. Maggie experiences horrible things, and has to live with the trauma. She is forced to do—and chooses to do— horrible, brutal things to survive, and has to live with the consequences of those decisions. This is not her dream, and, once experienced, no longer her fantasy. It is a world with hard people and harder choices.
Moreover, Maggie realises that her insight into the series now comes with an obligation. Appreciating that this land is, somehow, a real place with real people, Maggie now has responsibilities.…
Maggie’s story isn’t entirely bogged down in moral and magical challenges. Rellas is a buffet of hotties. Every man she encounters is a complete smokeshow; perhaps the series is unfinished as the author crumbled under the weight of their own lust. Maggie, as a mysterious outsider, soon finds herself the subject of attention from villains and champions alike, all of them equipped with heroic chins and smouldering eyes. (Literally, in at least one case.) As she settles in, Maggie builds a family around her as well. Not only attentive suitors, but a collection of lost souls that are drawn to her generosity and her fortitude. In a world where life is often selfish, Maggie’s commitment to others is a surprising and attractive trait. She earns trust, loyalty and, eventually, friendship. This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me does an excellent job of juggling the grimdark and the gracious….
This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me recognises everything we love about fantasy. It understands the heart of the reader, the desire not only to read the story, but also to be a part of it. Kingdom gleefully delivers moments of triumph and wonder and escape; the breathless joy of mingling with a beloved world and the heady power of being the center of attention. Kingdom also delivers the reality beneath the fantasy: exploring trauma and devastation; the grinding poverty and systemic brutality that would be “real” life in a fantasy world. It is a delicate balancing act, but one accomplished here with seemingly effortless ease…
A story about stories, and a fantasy about fantasies, [and] This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me is a gorgeous fantasy story in its own right…
<https://reactormag.com/book-review-this-kingdom-will-not-kill-me-by-ilona-andrews/> <https://reactormag.com>
Brad DeLong here: So sue me: I like, as Miles Raymer said <https://www.words-and-dirt.com/words/review-ilona-andrewss-this-kingdom-will-not-kill-me/>, a plucky hero/heroine “concerned with defending the innocent, surrounding herself with quirky and loyal friends, and strengthening social systems that promote peace and freedom while minimizing violence and tyranny”. This is metafiction: a book about how reading a book changes you and your life, carried to delicious extremes.
And, no, I will not be forgiving the author(s) for chapter 23 at all.
