(SEMI-)CROSSPOST: ELLE GRIFFIN: Why I Left SubStack
Is the SubStack social-media discoverability layer an aide to or an obstacle to the actual deep-engagement reading business we care about? And how would we design a better reading-salon experience than SubStack email + comments & referrals offers us?:
When 5,500 of Elle Griffin’s subscribers turned off email, they were supposed to be reading her in the SubStack app.
They weren’t.
Her essays flash past like tweets amid algorithmic recommendations and short-form posts. Her conclusion is that deep reading and mindless scrolling are incompatible activities that cannot share one platform. So she left and, with Claude, built her own: paid subscriptions plus print pamphlets, single-series and sliding-scale pricing, sentence-level commenting, and a membership club. I crosspost her case here:
<https://elysian.press/essays/why-i-left-substack?via=brad-delong> <https://elysian.press/>
(SEMI-)CROSSPOST: ELLE GRIFFIN: Why I Left SubStack
The world doesn’t need another social media platform. It needs the anti-social media platform.
Elle Griffin
As you now know, I’ve left Substack for a custom platform.
I left Substack because it’s social media now…. The app has become noisy—the home feed is full of social media posts and the article feed shows only five things by the people you subscribe to before devolving into algorithmic recommendations. My own husband, who only subscribes to my newsletter and one other, downloaded the Substack app to read us both only to never see a single one of our posts….
We needed the anti-social media platform. We need quiet places for long-form reading where we can spend 30 minutes absorbed in an essay without distraction, where we can foster long attention spans, and a life spent offline. Substack was that, once. Three years ago there was nothing to do on the app but read long-form essays and leave comments on them—I loved it. “Take back your attention,” was Substack’s mantra back then—now we have little control over it. I have to hunt through the app and change a bunch of settings to find the writers I subscribe to in the order they were published. Mostly I see a bunch of people I don’t subscribe to at all. I see short-form posts and notifications and whatever is algorithmically recommended to me. Because of the “social mediafication” of Substack I stopped reading in the app more than a year ago…. The app has chosen to emphasize discovery at the expense of reading…. And app users aren’t seeing essays. 5,500 of my subscribers have emails turned off—that was supposed to mean they are reading in the app instead, but they aren’t. Instead, article titles pass them by as if they are Twitter posts….
I don’t think Substack hatched some evil plan to destroy reading, it’s just happening naturally because they have to reach a mass market. The company has investors and expenses…. Becoming a pure social media platform is definitely their best bet to do that. Most people, after all, are not readers…. Two very different activities that require very different levels of attention. One involves scrolling dozens of posts mindlessly, the other requires focusing on one piece for a long time. These activities can’t happen in the same place—they are fundamentally incompatible….
Until recently, I had been at the mercy of whatever the tech gods built…. Claude became much more capable of building literally whatever I wanted…. And my new site is absolutely the retro upgrade of my writing dreams…. It is a newsletter with a website and paid subscriptions—but it also allows me to do things Substack never could… print pamphlet subscription… subscriptions that come at a sliding scale or allow readers to subscribe to just one series… host the Commons… redesign commenting—readers can now comment at the sentence level, and gift up to three “laurels” to other commenters…. And like a true social club, we now have a membership program!…. I’ve also added a lot of geeky things I’ve always wanted—the backend of my website completely replaces Google Docs with the most organized and beautiful place to write and research!
There are, of course, major risks to leaving Substack…. This is a renaissance Substack started—for a brief moment they proved there was still a market for reading, and that people would pay to follow their favorite writers. Substack has evolved to meet a much wider market, but we don’t have to. We can build for the readers only…. I’m excited to have the opportunity to do so. Thank you so much for reading and supporting what we’re creating with The Elysian,
Elle Griffin
<https://elysian.press/essays/why-i-left-substack?via=brad-delong> <https://elysian.press>
Brad DeLong here: If two information flows with opposite attention profiles try to share one platform, the one with the bigger market wins.
That is market-size arithmetic. That is why Elle Griffin thinks she needs to leave the SubStack app. And so she has vibe-coded her own platform, building which she thinks would have cost:
500,000 to $1 million, and about 12 to 18 months… rather than two months for $200…
<https://www.vibecodeapp.com/can-i-vibe-code-it/substack>. Her view: since the SubStack app is social media now, “then I will use it solely as social media”. Does this mean that she will still post SubStack notes linking to her own ElleStack? Let’s see: apparently not.
If I were her, I would keep my footprint on SubStack, with a SubStack note for every substantive post: Discovery stays on the social-media platform with network effects; reading moves to the quiet place with an attention focus.
I confess I find the SubStack discoverability layer useful enough not to want to follow her. But I am sufficiently annoyed with paper-cut frictions with SubStack posts and emails as eading platforms and SubStack editor as a writing platform to be tempted.
But should you want to follow in her footsteps? Consider Michael MacLennan <https://www.commswith.ai/applied/moving-applied-with-claude/>.
