Pre-Show: Hexapodia Podcast LXVI: Ryan Avent, Noah Smith, & Brad Delong: “In Good Faith: How The Nature of Belief Shapes the Fate of Societies”

We have: <https://open.substack.com/live-stream/462677?utm_source=live-stream-scheduled-upsell>

  • [ ] 2026-11-17 14:00 pst (tue): hexapodia lxvi: ryan avent, noah smith, & brad delong: in good faith: how the nature of belief shapes the fate of societies.

Share


Opening:

**Brad**: Noah! We need a new intro!
**Noah**: [something clever that sounds good]
**Brad**: But still the title of our podcast is the same: hexapodia.
**Noah**: Which is the key insight: a reference to the story in which the fact that something was six-footed. turned out to be of crucial importance; which we then generalize the idea that often some nugget of fact will, if grasp it correctly and place it in the proper context, transform your view of the situation…
**Brad**: The story is the late Vernor Vinge's mind-boggling science-fiction novel "A Fire Upon the Deep", in which an assistant librarian, two sapient bushes on scooters, and a zombie download into an explorer-raconteur's head from a dead cyber-god all voyage through space to save the galaxy from a great evil.
**Noah**: It might have been very useful for them to have known that they should heed the warning they were given: that hexapodia is the key insight.z nut they did not…

Give a gift subscription


Potential Topics & Notes:

  • 75000 years ago there were only, on some reasonable definitions of “us”, only about 5000 of “us”, wandering the plains of East and maybe Southern Africa at a standard of living of perhaps $3 a day, in jealous bands of 50 or so that occasionally mated with but more often were highly suspicious of each other.

  • That definition of “us” was, back then, outnumbered 400-to-1 by other hominids, with even the most closely-related of those—the then-extant hominins—leaving at most small imprints in our genes.

  • Yet here we are: 8.4 billion of “us”: and fabulously wealthy, with an average world standard of living now of something like $50 a day, or perhaps much more to the extent you think all of the culture and entertainment and other things that we get for pennies have substantial use-value.

  • And while we are jealous of each other, and while we do still kill one another at an appalling rate—well, you can’t get more than 1 adult male gorilla gorilla or 8 adult male pan troglodytes in the same room without big trouble, and some of them having to leave, or else, and we do coöperate at an immense scale, by and large.

  • Indeed, science-fiction writer Charles Stross claims that each of us could not sustain our current standards of living without drawing on a coöperative division of labor comprising at least 1/10 of our 8.4 billion population.

  • How do we manage to coöperate on such a large scale? Sarah Hrdy’s “allomothering” and gift-exchange.

  • And then, built on top of that, markets, hierarchies, bureaucracies, and what we might ungenerously call “ideologies” and more generously call “faiths”.

  • But even arms-length markets depend on faith. The economics textbook skips a step with Crusoe and Friday. Before they can trade, Crusoe has to teach Friday to speak. Shared meaning comes before markets. You have to trust that the butcher will sell you meat for money, rather than slaughter, smoke you, and sell you as long pig jerky.

  • For we are fundamentally cultural creatures who believe in things, and those beliefs shape our identities, our associations, the norms those associations share, and how and how much we coöperate.

  • Our innate capacity for faith—for belief—is the only thing that makes complex culture possible.

  • We are unparalleled at learning and preserving cultural information because we are overimitators: eager to copy others’ actions and beliefs without knowing the logic.

  • It is only the beliefs shared across the members of a cultural group that allow the group to function as an entity greater than the sum of its parts, as a real-ASI, an Anthology Super-Intelligence. Size and complexity allow for more sophisticated thought and a much richer set of potential responses.

  • Culture evolves: cultural evolution has over and over stumbled on new cultural tricks enabling more effective social cooperation at greater social scales.

  • This cultural evolution has a moral dimension: human progress relies on expanded possibilities for collective coöperation and cognition alongside and because of an upgrading of society’s moral beliefs.

  • Noah has offered three possible causes of that moral progress: full bellies, more information leading to more empathy, or “markets, property rights, police, democracy” taming us.

  • Ryan’s answer is that the moral upgrade comes first and enables the capability. So the question for the show is whether we became better people because we got rich, or got rich because we became better people.

  • We should understand our current troubles as resulting from a moral regression that we need to recognize and address. In a nutshell: Trumpism is a way to give ourselves permission to put our own interests above those of others.

  • Culture, faith, and broad social narratives matter: America’s business elite was not made of atomized maximizers but was heavily socialized. Democracy is government for grown-ups and is deeply, utterly faith-based—dependent on acceptance that the majority is in fact the best expression we have of Rousseau’s general will.

  • Market faith eats the fabric it depends on as incentives crowd out intrinsic motivation. (Fining parents for late daycare pickup and capping Boston firefighters’ sick days both backfired.)

  • Democracy is “government for grown-ups” and “deeply, utterly faith-based” (p. 221). The richest society in history is “brought to the edge of self-destruction because there simply aren’t enough people willing to sacrifice career for principle” (p. 226).

  • Culture, faith, and broad social narratives matter: The liberal world’s institutional crisis is an instructive historical event.

  • After all, background economic and geopolitical conditions over the past few decades have been vastly better than ever before, and the hiccups don’t seem sufficient to explain institutional dysfunction across so much of the rich world.

  • When a Faith decays, the void gets filled. Candidates include the Nietzschean Übermensch strain found “in places as different as Putin’s Russia, Modi’s India, Silicon Valley,” a NIMBY-plus-degrowth skepticism that “pulls up the ladder,” and the techno-optimist “gospel” of the just-build-it crowd, which Avent calls “a dead end” (pp.

  • What does the path to a better, more just, and more technologically sophisticated future look like?

  • Roddenberry mandated that the people of the future be better people, and Noah argues this is not pure fantasy. We gave up slavery, stopped burning cats for entertainment, and became far less murderous.

  • Thus Jean-Luc Picard is less alien to 2026 than he would have been to 1626. But moral progress “is not a smooth upward line,” and the last quarter century has been a reversal.

  • How does powerful AI invalidate or fundamentally change the cultural underpinnings of modern society?

  • Is the AI danger is not a killer robot but the “AI cocoon”? AI as therapist, romantic partner, and nursing-home companion. Ryan’s: “other people are hard. Who needs them?” Noah’s version: “If the Romulans attack us, it will be Claude or GPT who handles them.” Isaac Asimov’s novel “The Naked Sun”. So what is left for us to do together?

Share DeLong's Grasping Reality Weblog


Potential References

Leave a comment

Subscribe now

Share DeLong's Grasping Reality Weblog

Give a gift subscription

If reading this gets you Value Above Replacement, then become a free subscriber to this newsletter. And forward it! And if your VAR from this newsletter is in the three digits or more each year, please become a paid subscriber! I am trying to make you readers—and myself—smarter. Please tell me if I succeed, or how I fail…

##preshow-hexapodia-podcast-lxvi-ryan-avent-noah-smith-brad-delong-in-good-faith-how-the-nature-of-belief-shapes-the-fate-of-societies
##public-reason
##hexapodia-podcast
##preshow-notes
###hexapodia-lxvi
#faith-and-belief
#bourgeois-virtues
#yimbyism
#tabundance
#vernor-vinge
#gene-roddenberry
#patrick-stewart
#social-cooperation