A Very Little Knowledge of the Classics Is a Dangerous Thing: LAUGH OF THE DAY

For swords point in both directions. And during the Roman Civil War that started in the year -49 the swords of Rome and Italy pointed against the man who had dismissed the law:

Let’s give the microphone to Zack Beauchamp.

Share

He is talking about how Rubio and Hegseth are now quoting a serious loser, Pompey about how swords are more powerful than laws:

Zack Beauchamp: Might Makes Wrong: The Trump… catchphrase — “stop quoting laws to men with swords”… explains their… failure:

The Trump administration has a new catchphrase: “stop quoting laws to men with swords.” It started with Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who used the line in a Friday speech dismissing the authority of the International Criminal Court. It was picked up the next day by Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, who seems to enjoy this sort of masculine sloganeering far more than the actual work of running the Pentagon.

Though the line sounds like it was ripped from a Mussolini speech, it in fact originated with a somewhat older Italian: the Roman general Pompey. When the Sicilian city of Messana rebuffed his effort to impose control during a civil war, citing ancient Roman law, Pompey ignored them, offering the now-famous quip about laws and swords as justification. Pompey would ultimately die by his own maxim.

Defeated by Caesar in the Battle of Pharsalus, he fled to Egypt and sought refuge with Ptolemy XIII. Believing the Egyptian king owed him a debt, Pompey expected Ptolemy to welcome him. Instead, Ptolemy’s agents stabbed him to death as he attempted to get off the boat. This is, I think, not just accidentally embarrassing. It’s an irony that speaks to a basic void at the heart of the Trump administration’s worldview…

Give a gift subscription

I would note a different irony. During the crisis of the Roman Republic in the late fall of the year -50:

Plutarch: Life of Pompey <https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Plutarch/Lives/Pompey*.html>: ‘Pompey was elated, and his confidence filled him with so great a contempt for his adversary [Caesar] that he mocked at those who were afraid of the war; and when some said that if Caesar should march upon the city, they did not see any forces with which to defend it from him, with a smiling countenance and calm mien he bade him be in no concern; ‘For,’ said he, ‘in whatever part of Italy I stamp upon the ground, there will spring up armies of foot and horse…’

Share DeLong's Grasping Reality Weblog

from his veterans, the ex-legionnaires who had served under his command during his campaigns in the East. Caesar crossed the Rubicon in year -49 with only the Legio XIII Gemina:

to defend himself from the insults of his enemies, to restore to their proper constitutional standing the Tribunes of the Plebeians who had been expelled form the city in this affair, and to restore to himself and the Roman people liberty by freeing them from the oppression of the faction of a few…

Leave a comment

And armies did indeed spring up in Italy. But they—even Pompey’s ex-legionnaires—sprang up to support Caesar, who had, as Consul in -59, proposed and passed the Lex Iulia Agraria, granting public land for farms to Pompey’s veterans of the war against Mithridates and to poor urban Romans.

Swords point in both directions, after all. Laws determine which direction the swords of the good guys point.

Subscribe now

Share DeLong's Grasping Reality Weblog

Give a gift subscription

If reading this gets you Value Above Replacement, then become a free subscriber to this newsletter. And forward it! And if your VAR from this newsletter is in the three digits or more each year, please become a paid subscriber! I am trying to make you readers—and myself—smarter. Please tell me if I succeed, or how I fail…

##a-very-little-knowledge-of-the-classics-is-a-dangerous-thing-laugh-of-the-day
##neofascism
##laugh of the day
#a-very-little-knowledge-of-the-classics-is-a-dangerous-thing
#pompey
#julius-caesar
#roman-republic
#crossing-the-rubicon
#lex-iulia-agraria
#plutarch
#laws-and-swords
#rule-of-law
#marco-rubio
#pete-hegseth
#trump-administration
#legitimacy
#political-power