Econ 115 :: The World Economy in the 20th Century :: Lecture 2 :: Agrarian-Age Societies
The slides from the second lecture of my first post-big book excursion through the economic history of the 20th century; setting the baseline of agrarian-age societies against which we can contrast the 20th century…
& a start-of-semester sale for academic .edu email addresses only:
Slides:
2024-01-18 Th: Agrarian-Age Societies
Readings:
Crone, Patricia. 2014. Pre-Industrial Societies: Anatomy of the Pre-Modern World. Oneworld Publications. <https://openlibrary.org/books/OL34028800M/Pre-Industrial_Societies>.
Lecture Highlights:
Courtesy of Sub-Turing BradBot, responding to: First, identify and summarize the uploaded voice-recognized document. Second, please write a list of ten numbered paragraphs summarizing and explicating the most important and interesting points made in the document. The paragraphs should be long ones, more than 200 words and more than five sentences. Third, present me with highlights from the document, quoting the most important and interesting paragraph-length sections.
The uploaded document is a noisy transcript of a lecture by Professor J. Bradford DeLong on the topic of “The World Economy in the 20th Century,” specifically focusing on Agrarian-Age societies. This detailed transcript covers various aspects of economic history, touching upon themes like the long 20th century, globalization, industrialization, population growth, the role of technology, and the social, political, and economic structures of pre-industrial societies.
Now, I will provide a detailed summary, encapsulating the key points and insights from this lecture:
Beginning of the Long 20th Century (1870): This period is identified as a pivotal point in history, marked by increased globalization and full-scale industrialization. It signifies the onset of what the economist Robert Gordon termed the second industrial revolution, which brought about significant technological advancements and the formation of modern corporations.
Population Dynamics: The discussion highlights the dramatic changes in population growth patterns, particularly after 1870. There was a noticeable population explosion globally, except in certain regions like Sub-Saharan Africa and parts of the Islamic world, where fertility transitions have been slower.
Technological Progress Before and After 1870: Prior to 1870, global technological progress was slow, with only a 0.4% annual increase. Post-1870, there was a marked acceleration, with technology growth rates reaching 2% per year. This shift had profound implications for human welfare and economic development.
Role of Technology in Economic Growth: The lecture delves into the intricate relationship between technology and economic growth. It discusses how technological advancements have historically driven economic prosperity, but also how this relationship has evolved over time.
Pre-Industrial Societies and the Malthusian Trap: The lecture explores the dynamics of pre-industrial societies, particularly the constraints imposed by limited technological progress and the resulting Malthusian demographic pressures. This led to a cycle of slow population growth, poverty, and limited incentives for productivity improvements.
Governance and Social Structure in Pre-Industrial Societies: The lecture examines the role of governance and social structures in these societies. It discusses how elite domination and exploitation were common, with governments often more focused on maintaining their share of wealth rather than improving overall economic conditions.
Inequality and Resource Distribution: The discussion touches on how resources and wealth were distributed in pre-industrial societies, with significant inequalities and exploitation being prevalent. It also examines how societal responses to crises like plagues and famines could lead to changes in these patterns.
Cultural and Societal Changes: The lecture briefly addresses changes in societal attitudes and cultural norms, particularly regarding gender roles and patriarchy. It points to historical instances where societal changes led to shifts in demographic patterns and social structures.
Economic Models and Historical Analysis: DeLong discusses various economic models and historical analyses used to understand the dynamics of pre-industrial societies. This includes discussing the Gini index as a measure of inequality and how it relates to economic indicators.
Transition to Modern Economies: Finally, the lecture sets the stage for understanding how societies transitioned from agrarian-based economies to modern, industrialized ones. It lays the groundwork for discussing the economic, social, and technological changes that facilitated this transition.
In terms of quoting specific sections, the document is rich with detailed insights and would require more focused queries to extract the most pertinent and interesting parts relevant to your interests.
My interests are broad and general: Present me with highlights from the document, quoting the most important and interesting paragraph-length sections.
Here are some highlighted paragraph-length sections from the lecture transcript, providing insightful views on various aspects of economic history:
Equality in Society: “One could argue [inequality today is] significantly less important than in many societies of the past. Then there is the question of when the view came to be that people ought to be equal in some sense—that being equality was a good thing—rather than people being set in some kind of status value hierarchy by God or divine powers when that idea came along. The traditional thing to do is to attribute it to the religions of the book, to the Abrahamic faiths, and to their belief that we all must at some point stand the same before God as a key cultural moment…“
Modern Society &: Happiness: “We have people who are spending more time playing with toys than interacting with people, and it’s interacting with people that actually tends to make us happier. And our systems are not tuned necessarily to our benefit. Cf., Purdue Pharmaceuticals and the Sackler family deciding—or rather that the institution that is Purdue Pharmaceuticals decided, although no individual in it will ever admit to putting it this way—that it would be good for it to make money by addicting as many Americans as possible to oxycodone and such. That is not a way a good system should work. Yet that is what we got….”
Governance in Poor Societies: “It is unclear how you create the society in which it’s desperately poor but which governance is more than élite domination. There are, however, definitely times in which the elite domination is much less onerous—much more gentle, much more interested in creating an environment in which there is general peace [for] commerce and investment, so that average productivity is high—even if only because fat sheep when sheared produce more wool. These “efflorescences” of classical and medieval civilization are important. But they did not lead higher…“
Patricia Crone’s Pre-Industrial Societies: “This book is a generation and more old. We know a lot more about ancient pre-1500 history now than we did then. So why am I still assigning 57 pages from it? The answer is: I have looked, but I haven’t been able to find anything that is both more accurate and more informative and even half as readable. And I decided that readability needs to take preëminence here…“
On the Long 20th Century & its Innovations: “Robert Gordon likes to call what followed 1870 the ‘Second Industrial Revolution’. The first industrial revolution being the industrial revolution of steam that takes place around 1800. The second was a much bigger deal. Industrial research labs, full globalization, and the modern corporation. All happened around 1870. I think they happened to be final key…“
The Agrarian-Society Baseline: “This lecture will reach well back before 1870. It will focus on pre-modern societies agrarian-age societies societies from -4000 to 1500. I want to set up a baseline for how human life has been lived for most of history. Then we can focus on thereafter how different and remarkable and special the 20th century turned out to have been…”
Stage Theories: “Adam Smith back in the 1700s, and a number of his other friends in the intellectual circles of the Scottish capital of Edinburgh, started thinking about this in terms of stage theories: how different ways of organizing production, distribution, communication, and domination shaped human societies…”
On Post-1870 Modern Economic Growth: “After 1870 you have 2% per year of technology growth worldwide. Hsumanity’s wealth potentially doubles every generation. The possibility and soon the certainty of baking a sufficiently large economic pie for everyone to have enough by previous centuries’ standards—that gets on the agenda after 1870 in a way that it never was before. And that I think is the hugest deal in human history.”
Societal Evolution: “Adam Smith and company’s “commercial society” of 1500 to 1800—it’s not just commerce; it’s also gunpowder, and empire. And gunpowder and empire are as important as commerce I’d say in making those societies. Then, after that we get steampower society from 1750 to 1900 or so. And that is very different as well…“
Economic Narrative of the 20th Century: “What I strongly believe is the bigger, more important story is the one that runs from about 1870 to 2010: humanity’s success in unlocking the gate that had kept it in dire poverty, on up to the post-20120 failure to maintain the pace of the rapid upward trajectory in human wealth…“
Governance and Productivity: “It’s unclear how you create a society in which people are desperately poor but in which governance is not simply élite domination and exploitation. There are, however, definitely times in which that élite domination is much less onerous, much more gentle, much more interested in creating an environment in which there’s general peace, so commerce and investment can flourish to make average productivity higher…“
The Importance of Narrative: “Remember: We humans are narrative-loving animals. Stories with an exciting plot and an appropriate end of comeuppances and rewards fascinate us. They are how we think. They are how we remember. But individual stories are only important if they concern individuals at a crossroads whose actions end up shaping humanity’s path…“
Global Poverty and Inequality: “All around the world back in 1500 every society appears to be poor, roughly as poor as or even poorer as England was in 1500…”
bCOURSES HOME PAGE: <https://bcourses.berkeley.edu/courses/1531168/>
Course Procedures: <https://bcourses.berkeley.edu/files/87866083/>
Course Schedule & Readings: <https://bcourses.berkeley.edu/files/87866231/
Econ 115 at Schedule of Classes. <https://classes.berkeley.edu/content/2024-spring-econ-115-001-lec-001>
Econ 115 Piazza signup link: <https://piazza.com/berkeley/spring2024/econ115>